Showing posts with label Ocean View School District. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ocean View School District. Show all posts

Sunday, November 20, 2016

Settlement reached in Oak View neigborhood, home to National Treasure Historic Wintersburg

ABOVE: Broadcast media line up to cover the press conference detailing the settlement between Republic Services (parent company of former Rainbow Environmental Serivces) and Ocean View School District. At left is Vice President for Republic Services, Dave Hauser, and at right, Ocean View School District Board of Trustees president, Gina Clayton-Tarvin. (Photo, M. Urashima, November 16, 2016) © ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. 

   Settlement to multi-year litigation was announced on Wednesday, Nov. 16, 2016, for the Ocean View School District (OVSD) and Republic Services, the parent company of the former Rainbow Environmental Services (Rainbow).  Republic Services owns the Historic Wintersburg property, as of their purchase of Rainbow Environmental two years ago.  

   OVSD filed a complaint against Rainbow in 2013, after the Huntington Beach City Council approved by split vote a rezoning of the Historic Wintersburg property to commercial-industrial, including an action to demolish all six historic structures.  The OVSD complaint included the re-zoning, along with their air quality concerns.  

RIGHT: Historic Wintersburg Preservation Task Force chair and author, Mary Urashima (right), with Glenn Tanaka, owner of Orange County, California's Tanaka Farms, a supporter of the historic preservation effort. (Photo, October 8, 2015) © ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

   The Historic Wintersburg Preservation Task Force was formed in mid 2012 by the Huntington Beach City Council, after the creation of this blog in February 2012.  Task Force chair Mary Urashima has been actively researching and working toward the preservation of the Furuta farm and Wintersburg Japanese Mission for almost nine years.  She worked with a film crew on the PBS program, Our American Family: The Furutas, with a premier screening at the Japanese American National Museum.  The program aired nationally on PBS stations in 2015 and 2016.  Urashima's book Historic Wintersburg in Huntington Beach (History Press) was published in 2014.   

   Historic Wintersburg was named one of America's 11 Most Endangered Historic Places in 2014, and at the end of 2015, designated a National Treasure by the National Trust for Historic Preservation, Washington D.C. through the advocacy of the Task Force.  

   It is deemed potentially eligible for the National Register of Historic Places under Criteria A, Japanese American settlement of the American West, by the National Park Service---who inspected the property in mid 2013 at the request of the Task Force and then Huntington Beach mayor, Connie Boardman---and National Trust for Historic Preservation, who first inspected the property in May 2014.  The Historic Wintersburg Task Force has provided workshops and tours for the Consul General of Japan, the California Preservation Foundation, a Sister Cities delegation from Anjo, Japan, and media from around the country.

LEFT: A crowd gathers from around the community to witness the settlement announcement, made in front of the Oak View Elementary School adjacent to Historic Wintersburg. (Photo, M. Urashima, November 16, 2016) © ALL RIGHTS RESERVED 

   As outlined at the November 16 press conference, the settlement includes full enclosure of waste transfer operations to improve air quality and odor in the Oak View neighborhood, screening trees in the area between the school property and the waste transfer station, payment of legal fees, and up to $4 million for the construction of a new gymnasium on the Oak View Elementary School property.  OVSD also secured that no waste transfer operations of any kind will expand to the Historic Wintersburg property, notification for any "development, construction, demolition, or renovation activities...or any change or intensification" of the property, and "first right of refusal" should Republic Services decide to sell the Historic Wintersburg property.

RIGHT: Dave Hauser, Vice President of Republic Services, and Gina Clayton-Tarvin, president of the Ocean View School District board of trustees, after the settlement press conference. (Photo, M. Urashima, November 16, 2016) © ALL RIGHTS RESERVED 
    
Gina Clayton-Tarvin, president of the board of trustees for OVSD, clarified in a Facebook past for the Oak View neighborhood on November 17.

   "No inappropriate development at the Historic Wintersburg Site will occur. A recorded Agreement Between Property Owners will prevent the Historic Wintersburg Site from ever being used for an expansion of Rainbow’s solid waste operations, storage of garbage trucks, and various other uses inappropriate for a location adjacent to a preschool," Clayton-Tarvin explained, "The School District will have an option to purchase the Wintersburg Site at fair market value, and a right of first refusal in case Rainbow decides to sell the property to developers. These rights are assignable to other governmental entities or historical societies that may wish to purchase the property to develop a historical park facility on the site."

LEFT: Big smiles after the press conference. (Left to right) Huntington Beach City Council Member and liaison to the Historic Wintersburg Preservation Task Force, Erik Peterson, Republic Services Vice President, Dave Hauser, ComUNIDAD member Victor Valladares, OVSD board of trustees candidate, Patricia Singer, ComUNIDAD member Miguel Zamudio, and ComUNIDAD member Oscar Rodriguez. ComUNIDAD is an Oak View neighborhood organization advocating for community improvement. (Photo, M. Urashima, November 16, 2016) © ALL RIGHTS RESERVED 

   There currently are ongoing discussions between the City of Huntington Beach, Republic Services and the Historic Wintersburg Preservation Task Force regarding the next step toward historic preservation, with a heritage park goal. 

RIGHT: The Historic Wintersburg Preservation Task Force worked with Republic Services during recent street work and tree planting at Historic Wintersburg, providing volunteer cultural monitoring. This large enamelware bowl is one of the artifacts found buried in the earth, south of the 1910 Wintersburg Japanese Mission. More site investigation and cultural monitoring will occur on the property, as the preservation effort proceeds. (Photo, M. Urashima, August 24, 2016) © ALL RIGHTS RESERVED 

   Clayton-Tarvin also personally assured the Historic Wintersburg Preservation Task Force that OVSD's effort is to support heritage conservation, in keeping with the nine-year effort to save Historic Wintersburg.  Along with Republic Services, the Oak View community, the City of Huntington Beach, and heritage preservation experts, OVSD will be one of the stakeholders to provide input during the visioning and planning for Historic Wintersburg, which will include educational programming. 

   Congratulations are in order for OVSD and Republic Services in resolving an issue in a manner that also provides additional protection for the National Treasure Historic Wintersburg.  This is Orange County, California's first and only National Treasure historic place and one of two representing the history of Japanese Americans.  We look forward to announcing the path forward in the conservation and restoration of this rare and important American history.  

RIGHT: Historic Wintersburg Preservation Task Force chair, Mary Urashima, provides a tour to a group from the California Preservation Foundation during national Asian American Heritage Month in May 2013. The group pauses in front of the 1912 Furuta bungalow, contemplating the monumental civil liberties history represented. Urashima is now serving on the California Preservation Foundation's statewide historic preservation advocacy commitee. (Photo, Chris Jepsen, May 3, 2013) © ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

All rights reserved.  No part of the Historic Wintersburg blog may be reproduced or duplicated without prior written permission from the author and publisher, M. Adams Urashima. 

Wednesday, June 10, 2015

Urban Land Institute conducts Technical Assistance Panel at Historic Wintersburg

 
   Last week, the Historic Wintersburg Preservation Task Force was joined by the National Trust for Historic Preservation and the Urban Land Institute (ULI) for a Technical Assistance Panel (TAP) which will result in findings and recommendations regarding alternatives for the property's historic preservation.   

LEFT: The Urban Land Institute team at Historic Wintersburg, preparing for their inspection of the property. A dozen ULI panelists and ULI staff spent several weeks doing advance research and dedicated two days to working on the TAP in Huntington Beach.(Photo, M. Urashima, June 3, 2015) © All rights reserved.

   The ULI is a 501(c) (3) nonprofit research and education organization supported by its members.  Founded in 1936, ULI has more than 33,000 members worldwide, representing the entire spectrum of land use and real estate development disciplines working in private enterprise and public service.  

   Through the TAP process, ULI facilitates an open exchange of ideas, information, and experience to arrive at informed findings and recommendations for challenging land use issues.  The ULI strives to achieve a balanced approach through the selection of panelists and through the stakeholder interviews, engaging community members with differing opinions, backgrounds and expertise.

   The TAP process was facilitated for the Historic Wintersburg Preservation Task Force by the National Trust for Historic Preservation (Trust), after a major fundraising effort in 2014.  The Trust and ULI have conducted similar efforts for historic properties with challenging issues and diverse stakeholders, such as the Houston Astrodome (read more at http://www.savingplaces.org/updates/urban-land-institutes-bold-report-declares-astrodome-can-and-should-live#.VXjCp0ZLUg4).

RIGHT: A ULI panelist talks about the century-old pines at Historic Wintersburg, with pioneer descendent Norman Furuta, whose grandfather planted the trees on the property.  Historic Wintersburg extends its appreciation to the Furuta family for continuing to be a resource for historical information. (Photo, M. Urashima, June 3, 2015) © All rights reserved.

   In 2012, the Trust and ULI announced a new research partnership designed to advance the preservation and reuse of older and historic buildings in major U.S. cities (read more at http://www.preservationnation.org/information-center/sustainable-communities/green-lab/partnership-building-reuse/#.VXjBJkZLUg4).  This effort was initiated with ULI Los Angeles, the same organization which conducted the TAP for Historic Wintersburg.


LEFT: ULI panelists sequestered themselves for stakeholder interviews and panel deliberations at Huntington Beach's Main Street Branch Library, which itself is on the National Register for Historic Places.  Our appreciation to the Huntington Beach Libraries for their assistance with the two-day ULI TAP. (Photo, M. Urashima, June 3, 2015) © All rights reserved.

   Stakeholder interviews were an essential part of the TAP process.  Stakeholders included the property owners Republic Services/Rainbow Environmental, Oak View neighborhood  residents, Ocean View School District, Oak View Elementary School teachers and staff, Oak View Renewal Partnership, City of Huntington Beach elected and appointed officials, and the Historic Wintersburg Preservation Task Force.  Each stakeholder group had the opportunity to talk about issues, visions and suggestions for the property in a discrete setting to encourage open discussion.


RIGHT: The Huntington Beach Art Center also provided space for stakeholder interviews, in a quiet, private setting.  The Art Center is located directly across Main Street from the Main Street Branch Library and currently is hosting an exhibit on California Impressionism through July 4, 2015. (Photo, M. Urashima, June 3, 2015) © All rights reserved.

  A detailed ULI TAP report is expected to be finalized in about eight weeks (estimated to be in August 2015), with a release of the report coordinated with the Trust.  A public announcement regarding the release of the report will be posted here.

LEFT: Historic Wintersburg Task Force volunteer Barbara Haynes created an original work of art--representing the history of the Furuta goldfish and flower farm--for each ULI panelist. Panelists also received a canvas bag and tourism information from Visit Huntington Beach, and a signed copy of Historic Wintersburg in Huntington Beach. (Photo, M. Urashima, June 3, 2015) © All rights reserved.

Our thanks to those who supported this effort:

DONORS:
Over 100 financial donors from Huntington Beach and elsewhere in California and the West contributed to the fundraising effort, raising over $30,000 to make the ULI TAP possible, covering the logistical costs.  Additionally,  ULI panelists (representing experts from various disciplines in land use, preservation, economic development, and development) donated their time and expertise, bringing the actual value of the TAP analysis and report to over $100,000.  Donors will be recognized in the final report.

FACILITATORS:
National Trust for Historic Preservation
Urban Land Institute

STAKEHOLDER PARTICIPANTS:
Historic Wintersburg Preservation Task Force members and advisers
Republic Services / Rainbow Environmental
City of Huntington Beach elected and appointed officials
Mayor Jill Hardy*
Council Member Erik Peterson*
Oak View residents
Ocean View School District
Oak View Renewal Partnership
Oak View Elementary School teachers and staff

*City Council liaisons to the Historic Wintersburg Preservation Task Force.

HOST VENUES
Main Street Branch Library
Huntington Beach Art Center 

LOCAL BUSINESS SUPPORT
Duke's 
Jan's Health Bar
Sugar Shack
De Guelle Glass
Visit Huntington Beach


Inside the children's wing of the Main Street Branch Library, prior to the start of the ULI TAP. Library staff held the weekly children's story time in another area of the Library in order to make this room available for this community effort. (Photo, M. Urashima, June 3, 2015) © All rights reserved.


DONATION INFORMATION: See our page on the City of Huntington Beach website, http://www.huntingtonbeachca.gov/i_want_to/give/donation-wintersburg.cfm

FACEBOOK: https://www.facebook.com/pages/Historic-Wintersburg-Preservation-Task-Force/433990979985360

All rights reserved.  No part of the Historic Wintersburg blog may be reproduced or duplicated without prior written permission from the author and publisher, M. Adams Urashima. 

Monday, August 26, 2013

The ongoing effort to save Historic Wintersburg

The Furuta bungalow, lined with a beautifully trimmed hedgerow, August 2001. (Photo courtesy of the Furuta family)

*NEW* Tentative City Council hearing: October 7.


UPDATE AUGUST 26:
   On August 13, the Huntington Beach Planning Commission voted 4 -3 to certify the draft Environmental Impact Report (EIR).  The Commission then voted 5 - 2 to approve the General Plan Amendment and Zoning Map Amendment (ZMA, re-zoning) of Historic Wintersburg property to commercial / industrial.

    The Planning Commission denied, 4 - 3, the Statement of Overriding Consideration (the action that would allow demolition).

   The actions were subject to a ten-day appeal period.  As of last week, all three actions were appealed.


   The Ocean View School District appealed the certification of the EIR and the action to rezone the property, due to their concern about increasing industrial uses adjacent to the Oak View Elementary School.  

Ocean View Grammar School, circa 1926, included some of Huntington Beach's founding families.  In this photograph are Frank McIntosh (#7), Harley Asari (#10)--the son of Wintersburg goldfish farmer Tsurumatsu "T.M." Asari--Juanita Gothard (#5), Sumi Akiyama (#25)--daughter of Wintersburg goldfish farmers Henry and Masuko Akiyama--Toshiko Furuta (#31), and Lily Kikuchi (#33).  Children walked through the farmland to go to school every day. (Photo courtesy of Douglas McIntosh)

   The original Ocean View Grammar School was located at the southwest corner of Stanton (Beach) Boulevard and Wintersburg (Warner) Avenue, and the children of the former Wintersburg Village attended the school.  The present-day Oak View Elementary School is immediately adjacent to the south end of the Furuta farm across Belsito Drive.


Oak View Elementary School is located just south of Belsito Drive, at the bottom of this aerial photograph from the Warner-Nichols project draft Environmental Impact Report.

Portion of letter submitted on behalf of Ocean View School District at the August 13, 2013, Huntington Beach Planning Commission. (Click on image to enlarge.)

   As of Friday, August 23, 2013, the action on the Statement of Overriding Consideration (SOC) was appealed by City Councilman Matt Harper.


Excerpt from interoffice memorandum appealing the Statement of Overriding Consideration by Councilman Matt Harper.

Summary
   These actions mean the entirety of the EIR package, including the GPA, ZMA and SOC (including the proposal for demolition) will go before the Huntington Beach City Council for review.  Issues such as re-zoning impacts, analysis of project alternatives and justification of demolition will be reviewed again.

   The current information from City staff is that this meeting may be held in October (*New* tentatively Monday, October 7).  Continued support for the preservation of Historic Wintersburg will be  needed.

   More information regarding the upcoming City Council review will be posted as available.

WATCH: the full Planning Commission meeting on the Historic Wintersburg Youtube Channel, http://www.youtube.com/user/HistoricWintersburg/feed?filter=2

   Thank you again to all the supporters who came forward to speak.  We will continue our effort to save Historic Wintersburg!