Showing posts with label Wintersburg Japanese Presbyterian Church. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Wintersburg Japanese Presbyterian Church. Show all posts

Thursday, July 19, 2012

A Century Later: Wintersburg

The Furuta family at the tennis court on their property at Wintersburg (Warner) Avenue and Nichols Lane, circa 1920s.  Charles Mitsuji Furuta constructed the tennis courts for his wife, Yukiko, who had enjoyed playing tennis during her childhood in Japan.  (Photograph courtesy of California State University-Fullerton, Center for Oral and Public History)

Editor's Note: the next post on Historic Wintersburg will return to sharing history with information about the Tashima family, who owned a market in Wintersburg in the early 1900s.  Below is an update on the action taken by the Huntington Beach City Council, which affects the future of Historic Wintersburg.


   The Huntington Beach city council voted to establish an ad hoc committee regarding the historic preservation of the Wintersburg structures that include the Wintersburg Japanese Presbyterian Mission (1909-1910), manse (1910), Furuta family home (1912), barn (most likely prior to 1912), and Wintersburg Japanese Presbyterian Church (1934).

   The ad hoc committee will include three city council members, the property owner, and members of the community.  As a sub committee of the city council, these will be open, public meetings and those interested in the future of Wintersburg are welcome to participate.

   The draft Focused Environmental Impact Report(FEIR)---required by California law---will be released later this summer.  This report is to include alternatives for historic preservation in situ (onsite), analysis regarding relocation of the historic structures, and the application to demolish the structures.

   We periodically will post updates on the public environmental process and the ad hoc committee's efforts.

   Thank you to our readers who sent comments supporting preservation of Historic Wintersburg.


"These old buildings do not belong to us only, they belong to our forefathers and they will belong to our descendants unless we play them false. They are not in any sense our own property to do with as we like with them. We are only trustees for those that come after us."           
                                                                                                                       William Morris

All rights reserved.  No part of the Historic Wintersburg blog may be reproduced or duplicated without prior written permission from the author and publisher, M. Adams Urashima.  

Thursday, July 12, 2012

Wintersburg: What will be lost?

   "...take a moment and think of something significant to you personally. Anything. You may think of your children, or your spouse, or your church, or god, or a favorite piece of art hanging in your living room, or your childhood home, or a personal accomplishment of some type. 

   Now take away your memory. Which of those things are now significant to you? None of them... Without memory nothing has significance, nothing has meaning, nothing has value.

   We acquire memories from a sound or a picture, or from a conversation, or from words in a book, or from the stories our grandmother told us. But how is the memory of a city conveyed? 

   Here’s what Italo Calvino writes, 'The city ... does not tell its past, but contains it like the lines of a hand, written in the corners of the streets, the gratings of the windows, the banisters of the steps, the antennae of the lightening rods, the poles of the flags, every segment marked in turn with scratches, indentations, scrolls.'

   The city tells it own past, transfers its own memory, largely through the fabric of the built environment. Historic buildings are the physical manifestation of memory and it is memory that makes places significant."

      Donovan Rypkema, Sustainability, Smart Growth and Historic Preservation (2007),  
author of The Economics of Historic Preservation: A Community Leader’s Guide 
(The National Trust for Historic Preservation, 1994)

 
Wintersburg Japanese Presbyterian Mission, circa 1911, built with the support of people from around Orange County, California.  Wintersburg (now Warner) Avenue is a dirt road leading from the east end of Wintersburg (adjacent to Talbert) into the peatlands and wetlands at the west end. (Photo courtesy of Wintersburg Presbyterian Church)
 
 Today, the whitewashed Mission is hidden from view behind the 1934 Church building. (Photo, 2012)

Yukiko and Charles Mitsuji Furuta in front of their newly constructed home, circa 1912.  (Photo courtesy of California State University - Fullerton, Center for Oral and Public History)

Furuta family home, circa 2007.  (Photo courtesy of Chris Jepsen, www.ochistorical.blogspot.com)

Furuta family home, still retaining its red iron oxide paint. The Furuta barn also retains evidence of being painted with red iron oxide. (Photo, March 2012)

Reverend Junzo Nakamura and Sunday school group in front of Wintersburg Japanese Presbyterian Mission manse / social hall, circa 1924.  (Photo courtesy of California State University - Fullerton, Center for Oral and Public History)

Wintersburg Japanese Presbyterian Mission manse / social hall.  (Photo, September 2011)

Wintersburg Japanese Presbyterian Church, December 9, 1934.  The original Mission building stands behind this Church building, at the intersection of Wintersburg Avenue and Nichols Lane.  Congregants set down planks to stand on because Wintersburg Avenue (now Warner) was an unpaved road.  Note there are a few women in kimonos and that the gathering includes members of both the Japanese and Caucasian community. (Photograph courtesy of Wintersburg Presbyterian Church)

Wintersburg Japanese Presbyterian Church, circa 2007.  The widening of Warner Avenue left room only for a sidewalk in front of the doorway to the Church.  (Photo courtesy of Chris Jepsen, www.ochistorical.blogspot.com)

The peatland celery fields of Orange County, California, early 1900s.  Agriculture was the economic engine that provided for the development of modern-day urban Orange County.

The Furuta family farmland behind the barn was once home to the family garden, goldfish ponds and a tennis court.  It is now planted with nopales (prickly pear cactus).  (Photo, June 2012)

   "What neither the supporters nor the critics of globalization understand is that there is not one globalization but two - economic globalization and cultural globalization...Economic globalization has widespread positive impacts; cultural globalization ultimately diminishes us all. 

   It is through the adaptive reuse of heritage buildings that a community can actively participate in the positive benefits of economic globalization while simultaneously mitigating the negative impacts of cultural globalization."    
                                                                                                                  Donovan Rypkema


Call to action
    The City of Huntington Beach city council will discuss the potential for demolition or preservation of Historic Wintersburg buildings at their 6 p.m., Monday, July 16, 2012 meeting.  Help preserve this important part of American history by sending an email to the city council requesting they:
  • Direct a complete California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) analysis of all historic preservation alternatives, including both preservation in situ (onsite) and relocation for preservation
  • Make the historic preservation of the century-old "Warner-Nichols" Wintersburg property a priority
  • Deny demolition of historically significant buildings  located on the Warner-Nichols property, including the Furuta family home and barn, and the Wintersburg Japanese Presbyterian Mission, manse and Church
Emails should be sent by Saturday, July 14, 2012, to:

City of Huntington Beach City Council 
Public Communications  for July 16, 2012 city council meeting
Reference: Warner-Nichols (Wintersburg)
Instructions: 
  •  Go to http://huntingtonbeachca.gov/HBPublicComments/
  • Click on "Make a service request - Agenda & Public Hearing Comments"
  • Select request:  "Comment" 
  • Select: "City Council - Agenda & Public Hearing Comments" 
  • You may attach a letter/document, or, write your comments in the comment form
  • Your comments are automatically forwarded to all city council members, the city manager's office and the city clerk's office

Editor's note: Readers can find the full article, Economic Benefits of Preservation Session, “Sustainability and Historic Preservation by Donovan Rypkema posted on the website of the Preservation Action Council of San Jose at http://www.preservation.org/rypkema.htm

All rights reserved.  No part of the Historic Wintersburg blog may be reproduced or duplicated without prior written permission from the author and publisher, M. Adams Urashima.   

Wednesday, March 28, 2012

Voices from the past: Part Three, The oral histories



ABOVE: Yukiko Furuta standing in front of the Wintersburg Japanese Presbyterian Mission and manse, circa 1910.  These structures remain intact at Warner (formerly Wintersburg) Avenue and Nichols Lane. © ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

   Arthur August Hansen is Emeritus Professor of History and Asian American Studies at California State University, Fullerton (CSUF).  He is the immediate past director of the CSUF Center for Oral and Public History (COPH) and the founding director of COPH’s Japanese American Oral History Project.  He currently serves as a historical consultant at the Japanese American National Museum, holding the position of senior historian between 2001 and 2005.

   Historic Wintersburg continues with Part 3 of 4 of the interview with Hansen (see Voices from the past Part 1, March 12, 2012 post, http://historicwintersburg.blogspot.com/2012/03/voices-from-past-oral-histories-of.html, and Voices from the past Part 2, March 19 post, http://historicwintersburg.blogspot.com/2012/03/voices-from-past-part-two-oral.html.  
  
Present-day north Huntington Beach includes the former Wintersburg Village area.  The Furuta home and barn, as well as the Wintersburg Japanese Presbyterian Mission, Church and manse--at Warner (formerly Wintersburg) Avenue and Nichols Lane--have been called the "most significant extant Japanese American site in Orange County."  The earliest structures are over 100 years old--and the 1934 Church is over 80 years old.  

In Voices from the past Part 3 of 4, Arthur A. Hansen---delivering the keynote address at the 2008 annual Manzanar Pilgrimage at the Manzanar National Historic Site in Inyo County, California (Photo by Gann Matsuda of the Manzanar Committee)---discusses how the oral histories were conducted.

   The three most pertinent interviews with this connection were those done with Reverend Kenji Kikuchi, Henry Kiyomi Akiyama, and Yukiko Furuta.  All three of these Issei pioneer interviews were arranged by one of the two Nisei chairpersons for the project's initial History Committee, Charles Ishii.  I'd like to talk about how the interviews were conducted, and then discuss their content.

RIGHT: Rev. and Mrs. Kikuchi stayed at the manse of the Wintersburg Japanese Presbyterian Mission from 1926 - 1936, through the Depression and the construction of the new Church at the corner of Wintersburg Avenue and Nichols Lane.  See "The Wintersburg Mission," Feb. 20, 2012 post, http://historicwintersburg.blogspot.com/2012/02/wintersburg-mission-japanese.html © ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

   The interview with Rev. Kikuchi at his home in Huntington Beach (conducted Aug. 26, 1981), was the first interview conducted by me with an Issei.  However... I had conducted one with Charles Ishii eight days earlier.  Mr. Ishii was a longtime friend of Rev. Kikuchi and gave me excellent background information relative to the early years of the Japanese American community in Orange County and to Rev. Kikuchi himself.  Mr. Ishii also took me on an extensive driving tour of Orange County in which he pointed out and discussed significant historic sites bearing on the County's Nikkei experience.

   I recall that the Kikuchi home was located in a very well kept neighborhood and also that it was tastefully furnished and decorated.  Upon my arrival that particular afternoon, I was greeted not only by Rev. Kikuchi, but also his wife, Yukiko, and a young Sansei (third generation Japanese American), who I believe was the Kikuchi's grandson.

   At the time of the interview, Rev. Kikuchi--born in Japan in 1898--was eighty-three years old.  While mentally alert, he was then experiencing an assortment of health problems.

   It was a great blessing, therefore, that Rev. Kikuchi's Issei wife, Yukiko, sat through the entire interview.  She relayed my English-language questions to her husband in Japanese and often accompanied them with helpful interpretive gestures.  Much of the interview's success, in fact, is attributable to Mrs. Kikuchi, at time an equal partner narrator.

   Notwithstanding Rev. Kikuchi's health challenges, he radiated a warmth and good cheer rarely seen by me in any other people I have met in and out of interviewing settings.  It was both an honor and a pleasure to become acquainted with him and to interview him. 

   Rev. Kikuchi's taped testimony was very enlightening about virtually every phase of the community life of Japanese Americans in Orange County, but most especially for the period from the mid 1920s--when Rev. Kikuchi assumed his ministerial duties for the Wintersburg Japanese Presbyterian Mission--through the mid-1930s, when he moved from Orange County.

Henry Kiyomi Akiyama and his wife, Masuko.  Masuko was the sister of Yukiko Furuta; the Akiyamas had lived with the Furutas when they first married (Furuta home on Warner Avenue at Nichols Lane).  See "Full of hope for a new life", March 4, 2012 post, http://historicwintersburg.blogspot.com/2012/03/full-of-hope-for-new-life-in.html © ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
 
The three interview sessions with Henry Kiyomi Akiyama at his Westminster home were conducted when Mr. Akiyama was ninety-four years old (conducted June 10, 29, and July 27, 1982) .  He was born in Japan in 1888.

   It was to be my first experience interviewing someone through a foreign-language translator (in this case, Yasko Gama), and I fretted as to whether I would be able to get my questions to Mr. Akiyama posed precisely enough; something important, I feared, was bound to get lost in translation.  The recent death of Judge Stephen Tamura had dramatized for the (Bowers Museum's) Japanese American Council (JAC)  the urgency of interviewing Orange County's Issei survivors as soon as possible.

   Only the previous summer, Mr. Akiyama had been briefly interviewed for the JAC by my CSUF  Nisei History Department colleague, Dr. Kinji Yada.  I was concerned that this might well make Mr. Akiyama feel that his answers to my questions were somewhat redundant and therefore scale down his responses to them.

   To prepare, I talked both with Kinji Yada and Charles Ishii (present at Dr. Yada's interview with Mr. Akiyama) to secure background information useful for developing appropriate interview questions.  My preparation also involved reading the 1981 volume Through Harsh Winters: The Life of a Japanese Immigrant Woman by Dr. Akemi Kikumura, a younger Nisei anthropologist specializing in the life histories of Issei men and women.  This book was focused on her mother's life course.  (In 1991, a companion study by Dr. Kikumura centered on her father's life, Promises Kept: The Life of an Issei Man.)

   For the interview, I would ask a question, Mrs. Gamo would then translate.  Mr. Akiyama would answer in Japanese, and Mrs. Gamo would translate his answer into English.  I explained to Mrs. Gamo that my strength was in Japanese American history and that I knew very little about the history, culture, society and geography of Japan--and virtually nothing about the Japanese language.

RIGHT: Henry Akiyama, post WWII (circa 1945), at the Pacific Goldfish Farm.  (Photo, UC Berkeley Bancroft Library) © ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

   ...We were met by Sumi Akiyama, a Nisei who lived on the same property, in a separate house, with her husband--Henry Akiyama's Nisei son, Joe Akiyama.  The size of the property appeared to be about one to one and one-half acres.  In addition to the two houses, there was the Pacific Goldfish Farm, which the family (first Henry, then Joe) had been operating for sixty years.  (Editor's note: Akiyama's first goldfish farm was in Wintersburg, see "Goldfish on Wintersburg Avenue," Feb. 11, 2012 post, http://historicwintersburg.blogspot.com/2012/02/goldfish-on-wintersburg-avenue.html)

   Sumie Akiyama, who had coordinated all the arrangements for the interview with her father-in-law, led Mrs. Gamo and me...into the expansive living room, which was tastefully appointed and contained a large fireplace and open-beam ceiling.  Looking out into the patio, I could see a lawn and, behind it, an expansive vegetable garden.

   Mr. Akiyama, balding and wearing spectacles, was dressed in a grey checked shirt, charcoal alpaca sweater, and grey slacks.  Throughout the interview session, which lasted three hours, he was totally alert.

   During the interview (Sumie Akiyama) had apparently been harvesting vegetables in the garden for Mrs. Gamo and me, because she proceeded to give us each a sizable bag filled with luscious vegetables.  Whereas my bag contained mostly familiar American vegetables--green beans, squash, tomatoes and celery--Mrs. Gamo's appeared to be full of Asian vegetables such as daikon (giant white radishes), kabu (turnips), satsumaimo (sweet potatoes), and ninjin (carrots).

LEFT: Masuko Akiyama  at the Pacific Goldfish Farm in 1945.  (Photo, UC Berkeley Bancroft Library) © ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

   Sumie and Henry Akiyama toured me around the outside grounds, as well as the large greenhouse on their shared property.  I soon discovered that Mr. Akiyama, in spite of his advanced age, still nurtured an enormous variety of bonsai trees and raised numerous vegetables for the family's consumption (including a mountain variety of yam, nagaimo, indigenous to his native Nagano prefecture in Japan).

   We held two subsequent interview sessions with Mr. Akiyama (in 1982).  I prepared for these by reading W. Manchester Boddy's Japanese in America (1921); Robert A. Wilson's and Bill Hosokawa's, East to America: A History of the Japanese in the United States (1980); and Donald Keene's Living Japan: The Land, the People, and Their Changing World (1958).

RIGHT: Joe Akiyama at the Pacific Goldfish Farm, circa 1961.  Henry Akiyama purchased land under his son's name, due to the Alien Land Act of 1913.  (Photo, Los Angeles Examiner)

   Mr. Akiyama's son, Joe, supplied me with background information about his father's business career and the Akiyama family history.  We were impressed by Mr. Akiyama's prodigious memory and his penetrating insight, particularly in relationship to the goldfish farming business and the Nikkei community organizations in which he had participated before the outbreak of WWII.

   When the transcript of Mr. Akiyama's interview was returned to him in 1986 (for proofing and corrections), we learned his health had slipped a great deal.  Most of the changes on the transcript were made by other members of the Akiyama family.

LEFT: Mrs. Yukiko Furuta, wife of Charles M. Furuta, circa 1950s-1960s.  Yukiko moved to America to marry C.M. Furuta when she was 17.  She would take the "red car" (Pacific Electric Railroad) into Los Angeles for shopping and later became an avid Los Angeles Dodgers fan.  See "At home in Wintersburg," Feb. 22, 2012 post, http://historicwintersburg.blogspot.com/2012/02/at-home-in-wintersburg-one-of-few.html © ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

   The interview with Yukiko Furuta, the Issei widow of Charles M. Furuta, was conducted by me, along with translator Yasko Gamo, in two sessions (June 17 and July 6, 1982).  I looked forward to this interview with the sister-in-law of the prominent Orange County Issei, Henry Kiyomi Akiyama, whom we had finished interviewing only one week earlier.  I wanted to counterbalance the two male Issei interviews with an interview from the perspective of an Issei woman.

   A second cause for my excitement was my deep-seated longing to look around Mrs. Furuta's home on Warner Avenue in Huntington Beach, formerly Wintersburg, which her late husband Charles had built for her in anticipation of her arrival from Japan in 1912 as his seventeen-year-old bride.  I also wanted to get a close look at the historic Wintersburg Japanese Presbyterian Church and adjacent manse structures, which I had been informed were still standing on the five-acre Furuta property.

   To prepare, I telephoned Mrs. Furuta's daughter-in-law, Martha Furuta, the wife of Mrs. Furuta's son, Ray.  She provided me with an excellent background of the Furuta family and of the interviewee in particular.

   Although she was eighty-seven years old, Mrs. Furuta appeared to be in excellent health and possessed of a clear and vibrant mind.  Like most Issei women, she seemed short by Caucasian standards.  She wore eyeglasses, which heightened her dignity...she was attired in a pink dress, over which she wore a purple sweater.  On several occasions during the interview, she "hopped" up from her chair...to fetch Japanese tea (ocha) and Japanese rice crackers (senbei) for Mrs. Gamo and me.  The only indication that she was in any way hampered by age came from her remark that up until the current year she regularly traveled to Los Angeles--some forty miles away--to cheer on her beloved Los Angeles Dodgers baseball team at Dodger Stadium.

   Mrs. Furuta soon evidenced she could both understand and speak English quite well; in fact, she sometimes launched into her response to my English-language questions without waiting for Mrs. Gamo's Japanese translation.  The Furuta home stands quite near to Warner Avenue, now a very busy thoroughfare; the interview with Mrs. Furuta was conducted under less than idea sound conditions.

RIGHT: Charles M. Furuta--a charter member and first trustee of the Wintersburg Japanese Presbyterian Mission--he donated the land for the Mission and Church at the corner of Wintersburg (now Warner) Avenue and Nichols Lane. © ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

   We were delighted with our interview session with Mrs. Furuta.  She spoke movingly and in depth about... the immigrant Japanese experience in Orange County.  She had so much to say in this regard, that it was necessary to schedule a follow-up interview session with her.

   During the second interview, we remained at the Furuta home (all day), sharing several snacks as well as lunch with not only Mrs. Furuta, but also Martha Furuta and her then twenty-nine-year-old Sansei son, Norman Furuta (a graduate of the Stanford School of Law and then an attorney in San Mateo County).  He had made a special visit to Orange County so he could sit in on the interview with his Issei grandmother.  (Editor's note: Norman Furuta attended Huntington Beach High School).

   Norman Furuta, who was vitally interested in the whole process of oral history, led me on a tour of the Furuta property, which then still contained remnants of the pre WWII goldfish farm maintained by his Issei grandfather (C.M. Furuta).  During the tour, Norman related fascinating tales of his boyhood playing around the nearby (Wintersburg Japanese Presbyterian) church and manse.   Once the tour was over, Norman, with his grandmother, reviewed for me albums of family photographs, including some of a very historical nature.

   When the transcript of Mrs. Furuta's interview was returned to her for proofing in 1986, her health had deteriorated quite markedly.  Norman and his aunt, Kay Furuta Sakaguchi, reviewed the the transcripts.  They made many valuable additions and clarifications, and even enhanced the interview's value by providing a Furuta family genealogy.

Next in Part 4 of 4 Voices from the past: Arthur A. Hansen discusses his interviews with Rev. and Mrs. Kikuchi, Henry Kiyomi Akiyama, Yukiko Furuta and Clarence Nishizu.

ABOVE: Wintersburg Japanese Presbyterian Church congregation, circa 1926, the year Princeton-educated Rev. Kenji Kikuchi came to Wintersburg. © ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

© All rights reserved.  No part of the Historic Wintersburg blog may be reproduced or duplicated without prior written permission from the author and publisher, M. Adams Urashima. 

Wednesday, February 8, 2012

March 8, 1910


The congregation of the Wintersburg Japanese Presbyterian Church in front of the original mission building and manse, still at their original location near the Warner Avenue - Nichols Lane intersection.  Note a couple friendly dogs made the photo.

All rights reserved.  No part of the Historic Wintersburg blog may be reproduced or duplicated without prior written permission from the author and publisher, M. Adams Urashima.  
Postcard of Wintersburg Presbyterian Church


The new chapel, Japanese Presbyterian Church of Wintersburg, founded December 1904.

Sanctuary for a century


Japanese faithful have been attending Wintersburg Presbyterian Church since 1904, when it was founded as a mission.
By GREG HARDESTY / The Orange County Register Published: May 5, 2006
 

SANTA ANA - God and farming.


The black-and-white photograph captures the lives of many of the 600 or so Japanese immigrants living in Orange County in 1910.
   
In the picture, about 50 men in suits and four women in dresses stand in front of a tiny chapel that cost $675.85 to build on a plot donated by a goldfish farmer in Huntington Beach. One woman holds a baby.  Trees loom over the 18-by-40-foot chapel that was partially paid for by men who earned meager wages in the celery fields.

See the full article on the Orange County Register website at http://www.ocregister.com/articles/church-40721-japanese-wintersburg.html.

The Erasure of Community History

The Faces of Wintersburg -- Kazuo "Kaz" Masuda (center, in uniform) visiting his parents and family at the Jerome Relocation Center.  Kaz was with the 442nd Regimental Combat Team and was killed in Italy in 1944.   Kaz Masuda was posthumously awarded the Distinguished Service Cross and, in 2011, the Medal of Honor.  The Kazuo Masuda Middle School in Fountain Valley is named after him.  The Masuda family were congregants at the Wintersburg Japanese Presbyterian Church.

                  ______________________________________________

   California held the largest population of people of Japanese descent, or Nikkei, in the United States just before World War II, yet their historical presence is often invisible today in cities and towns where they farmed, fished, built businesses, and established institutions.  Wartime incarceration wreaked havoc on the physical and social fabric of communities across the West Coast, as well as on 120,000 individuals (over three quarters Californians). 

   At the onset of World War II, most Japanese Americans did not own their homes or places of business due to discriminatory early 20th-century laws restricting Asian immigrants’ rights to own property. Few Nihonmachi were able to regain their pre-war vitality, and many suffered yet again from urban renewal programs in the 1960s that destroyed what was left. The erasure of community history was one of the many painful legacies of forced removal and incarceration of Nikkei... 

See the full article by Donna Graves, Preserving California's Japantowns,  in the U.S. Interior, National Park Service publication, CRM: The Journal of Heritage Stewardship, at http://crmjournal.cr.nps.gov/05_report_sub.cfm?issue=Volume%206%20Number%201%20Winter%202009&seq=1

1986 Survey of Orange County's historic Japanese American sites

 Updated March 2022
 
   Orange County's Japanese American Council  in association with the Bowers Museum conducted a survey in 1986 of pre-World War II Japanese-related sites.  "Orange County's first Japanese pioneers arrived in the 1890s, but it was not until the early 1900s that they began to have an impact on the County.  Churches and schools served as focal points for small Japanese American communities that developed throughout the County.  By 1940, more than 1800 Japanese Americans lived here, farming over 11,000 acres."

The front side of the Orange County Japanese American Council's 1986 "Historic Building Survey" includes the Wintersburg Japanese Presbyterian Mission as the featured property.

   Many of the buildings included in the 1986 survey no longer exist.  The Wintersburg Japanese Presbyterian Mission is highlighted on the survey brochure cover and listed as number one on the survey. 
 
   The 1986 survey by the Japanese American Council coincided with the the City of Huntington Beach historic resources survey in 1986, which focused primarily on the downtown but did include the 1912 Furuta bungalow and "old Japanese Church" (Wintersburg Japanese Mission) with the designation of Local Landmark status. 
 
   A year earlier in 1985, the California Department of Transportation, aka Caltrans, conducted a historic resources survey along Warner Avenue to determine historic, cultural and archaeological properties. Caltrans final report prepared by Scientific Resource Surveys, Inc., includes references to the Furuta property and Wintersburg Japanese Mission complex historic significance and concluded the property was eligible for the National Register of Historic Places.
 
The south view of the Wintersburg Japanese Mission as it looked in 1991. To the right is the 1934 Wintersburg Japanese Presbyterian Church building. (Photo courtesy of Doug McIntosh.) © ALL RIGHTS RESERVED 
   
   Caltrans assessed historic properties "according to Cal Trans “Procedures for the Protection of Historic Resources,” (Section 106), M82—15, Appendix F. The guidelines mandate that the structures retain integrity of location and design in order to qualify for the National Register of Historic Places." The Caltrans historic resources report further remarked that the bungalow style architecture of the Wintersburg Japanese Mission and manse "may be the oldest surviving bungalow church structure in Orange County (Winter 1980)."  
 
   Update: both the 1910 Wintersburg Japanese Mission and 1910 Manse were lost to fire in February 2022 due to neglect and lack of security at the property by the current owner, Republic Services. The Historic Wintersburg property and its historic resources remain critically endangered due to ongoing demolition by neglect.
 
The 1910 Manse (parsonage) of the Wintersburg Japanese Mission as it looked in 1991. The Manse was immediately to the south of the 1910 Mission with a connecting walkway for the clergy. (Photo courtesy of Doug McIntosh.) © ALL RIGHTS RESERVED 
 
   The City of Huntington Beach did not conduct another historic resources survey until circa 2009, twenty-three years later. Approximately 70-percent of the historic structures identified in the 1986 survey were gone.  
 
   Update: When the results of the survey and its historic designations were received by the City Council and added to the City of Huntington Beach General Plan in 2015, the Historic Wintersburg property including the Furuta homes and Wintersburg Japanese Mission complex---each of the then-extant individual structures--were designated as eligible for the National Register of Historic Places. Also in 2015, the Historic Wintersburg property was designated a National Treasure by the National Trust for Historic Preservation. In 2017, Preserve Orange County designated Historic Wintersburg one of Orange County's Most Endangered.
 
   The historical designations--from Local Landmark to National Register eligible--must be considered during public environmental review under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) for any proposed land use action or change to the structures. The current status of the Historic Wintersburg property and its extant structures would require an Environmental Impact

The majority of Japanese American historic buildings listed on the 1986 survey have since been lost to demolition, neglect by present-day property owners, vandalism, fire, and redevelopment.

See the brochure at http://www.huntingtonbeachca.gov/files/users/library/complete/080221-5.pdf


The 1912 Furuta family home, circa 2007, facing what once was Wintersburg Avenue, now Warner Avenue. The second Furuta family home--the 1947 ranch house off Nichols Lane--was built post-WWII incarceration.  The windows of the 1912 Furuta home are boarded up in this image, although there is still a hint of the meticulously maintained gardens. The carefully manicured boxwood hedge were removed by the current property owner, Rainbow Environmental Services. Update: as of 2014, the property owner is Republic Services due to their purchase of Rainbow Environmental Services. © ALL RIGHTS RESERVED  

© All rights reserved.  No part of the Historic Wintersburg blog may be reproduced or duplicated without prior written permission from the author and publisher, M. Adams Urashima.